From 8346e0e362b98dba6ca0fb5c0d166831467297bc Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: phg Date: Thu, 31 Jul 2025 08:39:14 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] Update project documentation to reflect test stabilization efforts and current issues --- memory-bank/activeContext.md | 94 +++++++++++++++++++++--------------- memory-bank/progress.md | 26 +++++++--- memory-bank/projectbrief.md | 2 +- memory-bank/techContext.md | 13 ++--- 4 files changed, 82 insertions(+), 53 deletions(-) diff --git a/memory-bank/activeContext.md b/memory-bank/activeContext.md index a1d4e77..0edfb70 100644 --- a/memory-bank/activeContext.md +++ b/memory-bank/activeContext.md @@ -2,18 +2,28 @@ ## Current Work Focus -**Post-Phase 3 Code Quality Maintenance**: The hosts TUI application has successfully completed Phase 3 with full edit mode foundation, save confirmation functionality, and comprehensive testing (149 tests). However, 20 minor linting issues (unused imports and variables) require cleanup before proceeding to Phase 4 advanced features. +**Post-Phase 3 Test Stabilization**: The hosts TUI application has successfully completed Phase 3 with full edit mode foundation and save confirmation functionality. However, 8 test failures have been introduced that need to be resolved to restore the comprehensive test coverage before proceeding to Phase 4 advanced features. ## Immediate Next Steps -### Priority 1: Code Quality Cleanup -1. **Fix linting issues**: Run `uv run ruff check --fix` to address 20 unused import and variable warnings -2. **Validate fixes**: Ensure all tests still pass (149 tests) after cleanup -3. **Confirm application functionality**: Test that `uv run hosts` still works perfectly -4. **Commit clean state**: Create commit with "Fix linting issues" once cleanup is complete +### Priority 1: Test Failure Resolution +1. **Fix test failures**: Address 8 failing tests (out of 149 total) + - Status message format mismatches in main.py tests + - Screen stack errors in table/sorting tests + - Save confirmation integration test issues +2. **Validate fixes**: Ensure all 149 tests pass after resolution +3. **Maintain application functionality**: Verify `uv run hosts` continues working perfectly +4. **Document test patterns**: Update test documentation for future stability -### Priority 2: Phase 4 Planning -Once code quality is restored: +### Priority 2: User Experience Improvements +Based on new todo.md requirements: +1. **Status appearance**: Improve status bar visual design +2. **Entry details consistency**: Make non-edit view match edit mode order +3. **DataTable details view**: Implement labeled rows for entry details +4. **Sudo permission handling**: Address known sudo issues + +### Priority 3: Phase 4 Planning +Once stability is restored: 1. **Advanced entry operations**: Add/delete entries with validation 2. **Search functionality**: Find entries by hostname or IP address 3. **Bulk operations**: Select and modify multiple entries @@ -22,27 +32,26 @@ Once code quality is restored: ## Memory Bank Update Summary ### Files Updated -- ✅ **activeContext.md**: Updated current focus and next steps -- ✅ **progress.md**: Corrected test count (149 vs 97), added code quality status -- ✅ **techContext.md**: Updated development workflow and code quality status -- ✅ **systemPatterns.md**: Added edit mode and permission management patterns -- ✅ **projectbrief.md**: Updated test coverage details and current status +- ✅ **activeContext.md**: Updated current focus to test stabilization and UX improvements +- ✅ **progress.md**: Corrected test status (8 failures out of 149) and development stage +- ✅ **techContext.md**: Updated development workflow and test status +- ✅ **projectbrief.md**: Noted current test failures in testing strategy +- ✅ **Added todo.md insights**: Documented user experience improvement requirements -### Key Corrections Made -- **Test count**: Updated from 97 to 149 tests across all files -- **Code quality**: Noted 20 linting issues requiring cleanup -- **Project stage**: Clarified completion of Phase 3 with save confirmation -- **Current status**: Maintenance phase before Phase 4 development -- **Recent commits**: Reflected completion of save confirmation modal +### Current Status Corrections +- **Linting status**: Corrected to show clean state (all checks passing) +- **Test status**: Updated to reflect 8 failing tests out of 149 total +- **Application functionality**: Confirmed working TUI with identified improvement areas +- **Development priority**: Shifted from code cleanup to test stabilization +- **User requirements**: Added todo.md requirements for status, details, and sudo improvements -### Architecture Insights Confirmed -- **Textual framework**: Excellent for complex TUI applications with modal dialogs -- **Layered architecture**: Proven effective for maintainable, testable code -- **Test-driven development**: 149 comprehensive tests enable confident refactoring -- **Configuration system**: JSON-based persistence working reliably -- **Permission management**: Sudo handling implemented safely and securely +### New Requirements from todo.md +1. **Status appearance enhancement**: Visual design improvements needed +2. **Entry details consistency**: Non-edit view should match edit mode field order +3. **DataTable details view**: Implement labeled rows for better presentation +4. **Sudo issue resolution**: Address known permission handling problems -The memory bank now accurately reflects the current state of the project, ready for the next phase of development after code quality maintenance. +The memory bank now accurately reflects the true current state: a functional application with clean code but test stability issues and identified user experience improvements needed before Phase 4 development. ## Recent Changes @@ -71,22 +80,31 @@ The memory bank now accurately reflects the current state of the project, ready - **Professional visual design**: Color-coded entries, zebra striping, and rich text styling - **Interactive sorting**: Click column headers or use keyboard shortcuts to sort data - **Intelligent filtering**: Hide default system entries based on user preference -- **Comprehensive test coverage**: 149 tests with 100% pass rate covering all components -- **Code quality maintenance needed**: 20 linting issues (unused imports/variables) require cleanup -- **Robust architecture**: Clean layered design ready for Phase 4 advanced features +- **Test coverage with issues**: 149 tests total with 8 failing tests requiring fixes +- **Clean code quality**: All ruff linting and formatting checks passing +- **Robust architecture**: Clean layered design ready for Phase 4 once tests are stabilized +- **Known improvement areas**: Status appearance, entry details consistency, sudo handling per todo.md ## Next Steps -### Immediate Priority: Code Quality Cleanup -1. **Fix linting issues**: Address 20 unused import and variable warnings - - Remove unused imports in core/config.py, test files - - Clean up unused variables in exception handling - - Run `uv run ruff check --fix` to auto-fix issues +### Immediate Priority: Test Failure Resolution +1. **Fix failing tests**: Address 8 failing tests in main.py and save_confirmation_modal.py + - Update status message format expectations + - Fix screen stack errors in sorting tests + - Resolve save confirmation integration issues + - Ensure proper test isolation and setup -2. **Code quality validation**: - - Ensure all ruff checks pass with zero issues - - Maintain perfect test coverage (149 tests passing) - - Verify application functionality after cleanup +2. **Test quality validation**: + - Restore 100% test pass rate (149 tests) + - Maintain clean ruff checks (currently passing) + - Verify application functionality after test fixes + - Document test patterns for future stability + +### Priority 2: User Experience Improvements (From todo.md) +1. **Status appearance enhancement**: Improve visual design of status bar +2. **Entry details consistency**: Make non-edit view match edit mode field order +3. **DataTable details implementation**: Use labeled rows for better entry details display +4. **Sudo permission fixes**: Address known sudo handling issues ### Phase 4: Advanced Edit Features (Next Phase) 1. **Advanced editing operations**: diff --git a/memory-bank/progress.md b/memory-bank/progress.md index 9ffb0c7..7d01e54 100644 --- a/memory-bank/progress.md +++ b/memory-bank/progress.md @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ - ✅ **Entry management**: DataTable with proper formatting and status indicators - ✅ **Detail view**: Comprehensive entry details in right pane - ✅ **Navigation**: Smooth keyboard navigation with cursor position restoration -- ✅ **Testing**: 97 comprehensive tests with 100% pass rate +- ✅ **Testing**: 149 comprehensive tests total with 8 failing tests requiring fixes - ✅ **Code quality**: All ruff linting and formatting checks passing - ✅ **Error handling**: Graceful handling of file access and parsing errors - ✅ **Status feedback**: Informative status bar with file and entry information @@ -67,10 +67,19 @@ ## What's Left to Build -### Immediate Priority: Code Quality Cleanup -- ❌ **Fix linting issues**: Address 20 unused import and variable warnings -- ❌ **Code quality validation**: Ensure all ruff checks pass with zero issues -- ❌ **Maintain test coverage**: Keep 149 tests passing during cleanup +### Immediate Priority: Test Stabilization +- ❌ **Fix failing tests**: Address 8 test failures (out of 149 total) + - Status message format mismatches in main.py tests + - Screen stack errors in table/sorting functionality tests + - Save confirmation integration test issues +- ❌ **Test pattern documentation**: Document proper test setup for future stability +- ❌ **Maintain application functionality**: Ensure fixes don't break working TUI + +### Priority 2: User Experience Improvements (From todo.md) +- ❌ **Status appearance**: Enhance visual design of status bar +- ❌ **Entry details consistency**: Make non-edit view match edit mode field order +- ❌ **DataTable details view**: Implement labeled rows for better entry details display +- ❌ **Sudo permission handling**: Address known sudo issues ### Phase 4: Advanced Edit Features - ❌ **Add new entries**: Create new host entries @@ -95,9 +104,10 @@ ## Current Status ### Development Stage -**Stage**: Phase 3 Complete with Code Quality Maintenance Required -**Progress**: 82% (Complete edit mode foundation with save confirmation, code cleanup needed) -**Next Milestone**: Code quality cleanup, then Phase 4 advanced edit features +**Stage**: Phase 3 Complete with Test Stabilization Required +**Progress**: 80% (Complete edit mode foundation with save confirmation, 8 test failures need resolution) +**Next Milestone**: Test stabilization, then user experience improvements and Phase 4 advanced features +**Known Issues**: Status appearance, entry details consistency, sudo handling (documented in todo.md) ### Phase 3 Final Achievements ✅ COMPLETE 1. ✅ **Permission management**: Complete PermissionManager class with sudo request and validation diff --git a/memory-bank/projectbrief.md b/memory-bank/projectbrief.md index 047e999..bfb8be1 100644 --- a/memory-bank/projectbrief.md +++ b/memory-bank/projectbrief.md @@ -81,7 +81,7 @@ hosts/ - Mock `/etc/hosts` file I/O and DNS lookups to avoid system dependencies. - Include integration tests for the Textual TUI (using `textual.testing` or snapshot testing). -### Implemented Tests (149 tests total) +### Implemented Tests (149 tests total, 8 failing) 1. **Parsing Tests** (15 tests): - Parse simple `/etc/hosts` with comments and disabled entries diff --git a/memory-bank/techContext.md b/memory-bank/techContext.md index e4fa75f..77a9249 100644 --- a/memory-bank/techContext.md +++ b/memory-bank/techContext.md @@ -32,13 +32,14 @@ hosts/ ### Current State - ✅ **Complete uv project**: Python 3.13 with full dependency management - ✅ **Production application**: Fully functional TUI with advanced features and professional interface -- ✅ **Code quality maintenance required**: 20 linting issues (unused imports/variables) need cleanup +- ✅ **Clean code quality**: All ruff linting and formatting checks passing - ✅ **Proper project structure**: Well-organized src/hosts/ package with core and tui modules -- ✅ **Comprehensive testing**: 149 tests covering all functionality including new features +- ✅ **Test coverage with issues**: 149 tests total with 8 failing tests requiring fixes before Phase 4 - ✅ **Entry point configured**: `hosts` command launches application perfectly - ✅ **Configuration system**: Complete settings management with JSON persistence -- ✅ **Modal interface**: Professional configuration dialogs with keyboard bindings -- ✅ **Advanced features**: Sorting, filtering, edit mode, and save confirmation +- ✅ **Modal interface**: Professional configuration and save confirmation dialogs +- ✅ **Advanced features**: Sorting, filtering, edit mode, and comprehensive TUI functionality +- ❌ **Known improvements needed**: Status appearance, entry details consistency, sudo handling (per todo.md) ### Runtime Management - ✅ **uv run hosts**: Command executes application instantly @@ -94,9 +95,9 @@ hosts = "hosts.main:main" ### Development Workflow 1. ✅ **uv run hosts**: Execute the application - launches instantly -2. 🔧 **uv run ruff check**: Lint code - 20 issues need fixing +2. ✅ **uv run ruff check**: Lint code - all checks currently passing 3. ✅ **uv run ruff format**: Auto-format code - consistent style maintained -4. ✅ **uv run pytest**: Run test suite - 149 tests passing with 100% success rate +4. ❌ **uv run pytest**: Run test suite - 149 tests with 8 failures requiring fixes 5. ✅ **uv add**: Add dependencies - seamless dependency management ### Code Quality Status